OCD shows up in the craziest ways, my closet is messy, my
binders a mess, but by golly I have a beautiful looking reed when I play. Nothing
gets on my nerves more than people around me playing on terrible reeds. Without
a reed, there is no chance of producing a sound, making it the most crucial
part of the instrument. Do middle-schoolers get that? No. Even some high-schoolers don’t get it.
The first time that I worked with one of my students he
came in with a nice big chip right on the edge of the tip. Our first lesson?
How to send a reed to heaven. After explaining that there’s no way a reed will
play correctly if it is cracked or chipped, I asked him if he had a name for it
and if he knew how to send it to heaven. When he shook his head no to both
answers I took the reed and named it “Bob.” Then I looked at him straight in
the eye and drove the tip into the metal music stand in front of me, the result
being a deformed little hunk of reed. I have never seen a student’s eyes get as
big as his did after I did that! Since “Bob” was “no longer with us,” I gently
placed it on the palm of my student’s hand. We looked at it sadly for a moment and
I told him that he can conduct the “funeral” in any way he sees fit.
I also have a high school bari sax player that I see almost
every week. His tone was sounding a little fuzzy so I asked him to show me his
reed. There were the tell-tale little mold spots all over the flat part on the
back. He always had a good reed after my story. If you are frustrated with the
quality of students’ reeds, tell them this story and they will keep their reeds
in mint condition! Story time!
A band director
was preparing her band to go to concert and sight reading contest. During one
rehearsal her bari sax player couldn't get a sound out. The first thing she had
him do was take off the reed and show it to her, but after struggling for a few
moments it was apparent that the reed was stuck to the mouthpiece. He had not
taken it off for about a month. Once he did get the reed off, both the student
and the director were horrified to see long, black, hairy mold and little white
creatures wiggling on the reed. The student managed to contain his shock long
enough to ask if he could buy a new reed, but the director looked at him and
whispered to him to put it back on the mouthpiece and play until the end of
rehearsal. Wide eyed student seemed to turn a slight shade of green as he
walked back, but he managed to survive rehearsal without seeing is lunch again.
If that is not creepy and disgusting enough motivation for
any student to take care of their equipment, I don’t know what is! Ever since
then I can’t stand to see bad reeds, much less one that is starting to show
signs of mold. Must be my OCD taking over again...
EEEEEEEEEEW! This totally happened at my school too! a tenor sax player found maggets on his reed, and we all threw up in our mouths a little bit.
ReplyDeleteI have not had a single student come in with even a slightly moldy reed since I started telling this story! You should use your story in your classes if you have problems with instrumentalists not taking care of their reeds.
ReplyDeleteEW!! SO GROSS! That would definitely be inspiration for me to always have my reed in pristine condition! But this is a very funny post, and you have a nice, clear writing style. Thumbs up. :)
ReplyDeleteThat is so gross!! I was in band during my junior high years, and this one girl always left her reed on her clarinet. At competition she went to exchange her reed and she could not get it off of her clarinet, because it was stuck like super glue. She had to play with it during the entire competition.
ReplyDeleteAfter I read this post I only thought one thing... WOW! I like that you told your student a story instead of scolding them to get your point across. In kinder garden (this story is not completely first hand because I think I blocked most of it out. My mom has told me this story once or twice) I spilled my snacks and made a mess on the floor. On that day parents were visiting, and all of them plus their children watched as she screamed at me to pick everything up, making a big scene. Before I could really start crying thankfully my mom intervened (My mom seems to have cut the ending part out of the story, and maybe I don't want to know exactly what she told that teacher). Methods like the ones you chose are much more effective than others (like my story obviously). So I applaud the fact that you came up with a way to teach your student in a calm manner.
ReplyDelete